Best sound to block office talking: what offices have tested

By Luis5 min read

To block office talking, use a steady sound with no words or tune, such as pink noise or running water, at the lowest level that stops you following the conversation. In a lab test of five masking sounds for open-plan offices, researchers recommended constant sounds over instrumental or vocal music. Masking helps, but it does not bring you back to silence: most masked conditions in that study still hurt short-term memory compared with a silent room.

This article is written by Luis, who makes Kiri, which plays pink noise and water sounds. The studies below tested sound played through an office or lab, not through personal headphones, so applying them at your desk is a reasonable step and not a tested one.

What was tested

Haapakangas and colleagues (2011) tested 54 people in seven conditions: speech, silence, and speech masked by filtered pink noise, ventilation noise, instrumental music, vocal music or spring water. Participants did short-term memory, proofreading and creative thinking tasks.

Compared with silence, short-term memory got worse with speech and with most masked speech conditions. Compared with plain speech, performance improved when it was masked with the sound of spring water. People also rated the masked conditions as a better working environment. The authors recommended constant masking sounds instead of music.

The lab preference for water did not carry over cleanly to a real office. Hongisto and colleagues (2017) tried four water-based sounds for three weeks each in an open-plan office of 77 people, against the artificial masking already in use at about 44 dB. Staff were less satisfied with the water sounds, and colleagues' speech disturbed them more. They were used to the existing sound, which may have played a part.

Sources: Haapakangas et al. (2011), "Effects of Five Speech Masking Sounds on Performance and Acoustic Satisfaction", Acta Acustica united with Acustica, 97(4). Hongisto et al. (2017), "Perception of Water-Based Masking Sounds", Frontiers in Psychology, 8.

What to play at your desk

  • Start with pink noise or a water sound. Both have energy across the range where speech sits, and neither has words.
  • Use brown noise with care. Its energy sits low, so it softens voices without covering them as fully. See brown vs white noise.
  • Skip vocal music for reading and writing. Lofi or brown noise goes through the research on lyrics.
  • Keep it low. Turning sound up to beat a loud room has a cost, explained in how loud is safe. Closed or noise-cancelling headphones help you keep it down.
  • Move if you can. For memory-heavy work, short-term memory was better in silence than in most of the masked conditions tested.

Where Kiri fits, and who should not use it

Kiri is a focus timer for laptops and desktops with ten ambient sounds in the same tab. Pink, white and brown noise are generated, not recorded. Brown noise plays in full with no account, and a free account adds rain in full; pink noise and the other soundscapes are part of the full version, €39 once at the Founding price and €49 after 500 licences. With no account you get 100-second samples on repeat. If you only want free pink noise and no timer, a free generator such as myNoise may suit you better. Kiri has no phone app.

Questions

What is the best sound to drown out talking at work?

A steady sound with no words, such as pink noise or running water, at the lowest level that stops you following the conversation. A lab study of open-plan office sounds recommended constant sounds over music.

Does white noise block voices?

It can reduce how much of a conversation you follow, because it covers the frequencies where speech sits. It will not remove voices entirely, and it can sound harsh.

Is masking noise as good as silence?

No. In the 2011 lab study, short-term memory was worse with speech and with most masked speech conditions than in silence.

Is water or pink noise better for masking?

It is unsettled. Spring water did well in a lab test, but staff in a real office preferred their existing artificial masking over water sounds during a three-week-per-sound trial.